TAP3 - Unanderra Station Upgrade - ISCouncil

TAP3 – Unanderra Station Upgrade

Project Details

  • Rating Type: V 1.2 Design and As Built
  • Location: NSW
  • Rating Level: Leading
  • IS Project manager: Diego Uzzun
  • Stakeholders: Proponent: Transport for NSW ,Head Contractor: Degnan ,Design partners: Arcadis and Design Inc. ,Sydney Trains

The Unanderra Station Upgrade Project (the Project) is part of the third tranche of Transport for NSW’s Transport Access Program, known as TAP 3 and seeks to improve access to public transport for people with disability or limited mobility, parents and careers with prams, and customers with luggage. Providing accessible transport services for everyone in the community is one of the six priorities for Transport for NSW’s Future Transport Strategy.

Upgrading train stations will provide fair and equitable access for all customers, as well as improve connections between the station and key destinations in the area. The Unanderra Station Upgrade Project provides:

  • A new enclosed footbridge with three new lifts connecting the existing island platform to adjacent streets
  • platform modifications, including minor platform regrading and line marking of boarding assistance zones on Platform 1 and 2
  • modification of the existing station building layout for the provision of a new family accessible toilet
  • provision of an accessible kiss and ride bay on Berkeley Road (east), with a new access path to the station entrance including new kerb ramps
  • provision of an accessible kiss and ride bay on Berkeley Road (west), including a widened footpath and a kerb ramp
  • conversion of the existing non-compliant DDA parking spaces on Berkeley Road (west) into three accessible parking spaces with shared zones
  • provision of accessible footpaths on Berkeley Road (west) between the station entrance, kiss and ride, bus zone and accessible parking spaces
  • removal of the existing footbridge

Scope optimisation

The initial concept design favoured utilising the existing footbridge, with new lifts end elevated linkways connecting to it. Through principals of Urban Design, Value Management and whole-of-life-cost, Degnan and TfNSW collaborated to re-design the project with a new footbridge and lifts, and demolish the old footbridge.

Principle advantages of new vs. old were:

  • Cost Effectiveness: While the initial Capital Expenditure (CapEx) was higher, the subsequent Operational Expenditure (OpEx) proved significantly lower. This resulted in an overall reduction in the life cycle cost of the project.
  • Regulatory Compliance: The new bridge was designed with the latest regulatory infrastructure standards and codes. Given the age of the old bridge, full compliance with the newest standards and codes would have been challenging and required concessions to the standards.
  • Enhanced Design Aesthetics and Accessibility: The new footbridge showcases a distinctly improved design aesthetic and boasts enhanced accessibility features. These improvements serve to benefit patrons and uplift the community.
  • Mitigated Risk: Opting to replace the existing footbridge averts potential construction, safety, and scheduling risks associated with such replacement in the mid-2040s.
  • Risk Minimisation: The strategic choice to avoid constructing new infrastructure adjacent to hazardous services, such as live high-pressure gas mains and high-pressure water mains, effectively eliminated construction-related risks.
  • Continued Operation: Throughout the construction phase, the existing footbridge was maintained, ensuring ongoing station access for patrons and minimising disruption for all users.

By thoughtfully considering these advantages, the project has not only ensured fiscal prudence but has also demonstrated a commitment to compliance, safety, accessibility, and the welfare of the community and stakeholders.

As Built Rating Highlights 

Category  Credit  Achievements/ Description 
People and Place  Hea-1, Sta-2 Her-1  Co-Design with Local Aboriginal Elders and Knowledge Holders  

The Project made a significant effort to comprehensively engage with the local Aboriginal community to collaborate on the Aboriginal design for the Project. For Unanderra, this has meant seeking to understand, in conversation with local people, some of the themes, narratives and/or organising principles that can enrich the design of the station landscape and buildings. This process was ongoing, as the challenges of COVID lockdown made it difficult, if not impossible, to meet in person.  

Unanderra is within the Dharawal Nation, and its traditional custodians are the Wodi Wodi – Saltwater People.  Because of its location between the steep Illawarra escarpment and the Pacific Ocean, the coastal plain supports many diverse vegetation communities as well as fish, crustacea and seabirds, and is an abundant and rich source of food and materials. 

The Aboriginal experience of the landscape is one of Custodianship for the Dharawal people. Their language group expands from the inland rivers and creeks that flow down the escarpment and to the coastline of the Illawarra. The connection of the Dharawal People to place stems from the landscape and further defines their kindship ties to subgroupings defined by the characteristics of the water in the streams.  

  • Sweet-water – western inland streams 
  • Bitter-water – brackish waters of the lakes and lagoons 
  • Salt-water – lands by the sea  

 The Wodi Wodi Dharawal are Saltwater people, defined by their relationship to the Illawarra escarpment and out into the sea. Mount Kembla, a dominant feature on the Skyline is called “jum-bullah” or “Djembla” which means wallaby and is culturally significant site. Unanderra is an Aboriginal word meaning “the meeting place of creeks”, referring to the junction between Charcoal and Allans Creek (Wollongong Library). 

Even though COVID restrictions made the preferred method of engagement more difficult, the Project adopted a methodology for engagement for culturally appropriate and respectful consultation through:  

  • Research and identify traditional custodians and knowledge holders 
  • Connect with custodians in a collaborative way to explore culturally appropriate outcomes 
  • Sensitive cultural mapping beyond the immediate site to explore broader cultural themes 
  • Indigenous design approach - stories of country translated into the built environment 
  • Co-design with traditional knowledge holders and seek permission to bring their narratives into built form 
  • Ensure traditional knowledge holders are recognised, both financially and credited for their design involvement. 

Using this process, Wodi Wodi born architect Craig Kerslake has been working with the team, including bringing some of the learnings gathered from the Aboriginal Interpretation work for Towradgi Station, which is also on Wodi Wodi Country. 

Additionally, a meeting with Paul Knight, chair of the Illawarra Aboriginal Land Council, occurred to introduce the project and request guidance around opportunities to embed Designing with Country into the design.  Paul has worked closely with GANSW, including running information and training sessions on Designing with Country for practitioners. Our learnings from these conversations were: 

  • The landscape was the primary opportunity to represent Country, in several ways: 
  • The design itself, acknowledging that this is a ‘place’ not just a ‘through route’ to the station.  We therefore started to consider how the design could encourage people to see and appreciate the natural environment  
  • The use of local endemic species – a palette that can be added to or modified in consultation with local Knowledge Holders, as part of a co-design process  
  • Sourcing plants and contracting the landscape delivery through Indigenous-owned businesses. This is important to provide employment opportunities and genuinely involve the local Aboriginal community as participants in the station upgrade and its ongoing use. 
  • While there are many stories, it is important to consider living culture, not just historical narratives, or themes.  To that end, we have taken a step back from representing a particular theme or narrative at Unanderra. Instead, the philosophy of ‘being in place’ thinking, and highlight the experience of being in the landscape, viewing natural landmarks, and orienting paths of travel around key cultural landscape features was implemented. The places and spaces within the station that these experiences allowed for and encouraged are:  
  • The east side of the station, where there is the most space for landscape treatment, 
  • The new overbridge stair towers detail draw reference from the adjacent escarpment with a modern interpretation of the sandstone cliff faces,  
  • Creating and focusing new elevated views as a point of reference towards Mount Kembla, which is significant culturally and geographically. 

The Project’s design includes the following concepts / ideas that relate to Country:   

  1. A soft landscape that acknowledges the deep history of the place through planting 
  2. An arrival / departure experience that encourages a ‘gentle journey’ with places to rest, meet, talk and enjoy the (restored) natural setting,  
  3. Strong acknowledgement of the “Two River Story” provided by Coomaditchie in paving or low retaining garden bed walls, communicating that this is Dharawal Country, 
  4. The creation of a small lookout area at the western end of the footbridge from which to see and locate the viewer in relation to Mt Kembla 

The team explored how planting, materials, textures and colours can help enhance a sense of place and of the station being part of and contributing to the life and landscape of Unanderra. Additional conversations with Knowledge Holders were held, as they were able to speak with us, to discuss other thoughts and suggestions for the Project. 

Coomaditichie was then engaged to produce the draft artworks which were then incorporated into the design to transform the paths leading to the station into the Two Rivers Story. The artwork provided became the direct expression of traditional cultural symbols and storytelling and are a strong and authentic representation of the Dharawal culture.   

Figure 1 Design drafts of interpretation artwork 

Figure 2 Artwork design locations 

Figure 3 Implemented “Being in Place” artwork 

Biophilic Design  

Another concept / story which arose through the design and consultation process was the concept that Unanderra station has developed a response to the physical site conditions. The station design is inspired by the nearby natural forms of Illawarra Escarpment to connect people with a sense of place as they arrive and depart. 

Figure 4 Concept design drawings of escarpment connection 

 

Figure 5 Render of escarpment connection design 

Figure 6 Completed Project incorporating escarpment symbolism 1 

Figure 7 Completed Project incorporating escarpment symbolism 2 

 

The final built form included angular canopies, angular mouldings and glazing on the lift shafts, and curved and coloured pavements to reflect the design and codesign principles. Maximising natural light, airflow and increasing the available green space through design allowed for a stronger connection back to the natural environment. 

Figure 8 Finished project incorporating Aboriginal artworks 

Interpretation of historic elements  

The Project identified an opportunity to provide an educational, interpretation sign for two historic items located at Unanderra Station. 

  1. The Station Master’s Residence  

Located next to the station itself is the historic Station Master’s Residence. What makes the Station Master’s Residence interesting is that it is not only a government railway building but it was always intended to be a home. Since its construction in 1887 and up until the late 1990s, the Unanderra Station Master’s Residence was occupied by a Station Master and, in most cases, their family as well.  

Station Masters were often upstanding members of the local community at Unanderra, being critical caretakers of the local economy. Without an operational railway station, many of Unanderra's local businesses, such as the coke factory and collieries, tanneries, farms and dairies, would have struggled to get their products to market in Port Kembla, Wollongong and Sydney. 

  1. Thornley Level Frame Type-45  

The Thornley Type-45 Lever Frame was used at Unanderra Station during a time of significant industrial growth for the suburb and surrounding areas, which resulted in the Good Sidings track being built. Most of the local growth was attributed to steel production at the nearby steelworks, which remains to this day. The Thornley Level was placed on one of these goods sidings and was used to operate the points along the siding to ensure rail cars could safely be moved from one track to another without derailing. The frame was manually operated, which was common for these kinds of levers. 

Figure 9 Thornley lever design 

Degnan went above and beyond the Project’s scope to restore the Thornley Level and to design and install an interpretive sign describing the significance of the Lever in the historical context of Unanderra Station and the surrounding Yard, as well as detailing the important history of the Station Master’s Residence. 

Figure 10 Restored Thornley lever and information sign 1 

Figure 11 Restored Thornley lever and information sign with Station Master’s Residence in background  

 

Figure 12 Thornley lever Information sign 

Figure 13 Western station entry with Thornley lever 

Materials  Mat-1  Circular Economy / Sustainable materials  

The Project achieved a 23% IS EnviroPoint reduction as compared to the Base Case, this is the equivalent of avoiding 516.83 tonnes of CO2-e in embodied form (i.e. Scope 3 emissions). This saving was achieved through initiatives such as:  

  1. Minimising the use of Portland cement in concrete mixes and replacing it with supplementary cementitious material (SCM). The Project achieved an average of 42% (SCM), with some mixes as high as 61% SCM.  
  2. Optimised engineering solution to eliminate the need for ‘deflection walls’, a significant saving of concrete (237 m3) and steel (70 tons).  
  3. Using recycled asphalt content within asphalt mixes, up to 15% 

The Project achieved Level 2.53 for Mat-1.  

Waste  Was-1, Was-2  In addition to the above material reductions, the Project prioritised its Circular Economy approach as the re-use of several impactful elements: 

 

Use of recycled quarry materials  

Throughout the Project, recycled quarry materials such as crushed concrete & bricks, recycled crushed glass sand and others were used in the earthworks and services to avoid virgin material usage wherever practical. 

 

Reuse of 'Philips GreenVision Exceed' light fittings 

Before the removal of the old footbridge at Unanderra Station, the Project team carefully removed and stored the light fittings off the footbridge which were still within their useful design life. Degnan was able to find another location where the light fittings could be used on another Transport Access Program Upgrade as semi-permanent lighting to illuminate walkways for train drivers in a rail yard, adjacent to the works areas. 

Energy and GHG emissions  Ene-1  

Ene-2 

Energy/GHG Reductions 

The Project has achieved a 59% life-cycle greenhouse gas emissions reduction as compared to the Base Case scenario; considering both construction and operational energy use (i.e. Scope 1 and Scope 2), this is the equivalent of 275 t CO2-e being saved. The Project achieved Level 2.93 for the Ene-1 ISC Credit.  

 

The main Project initiatives which contributed to the energy savings were: 

  • For operations, installing an instantaneous domestic hot water system (replacing the old inefficient system)  
  • For construction, installation of an innovative solar / battery system (provided by Makinex) to power site sheds and facilities decreasing the Project’s reliance on diesel generators or grid electricity.   

Figure 13 Australian-First Container-top solar PV system  

Combined with the material savings of 516 t CO2-e, the Project’s lifetime avoided carbon is 791 t CO2-e. 

 

Verified Innovations 

Innovation Name   Description 
Inn-1.2 Exceeding Small Project Pathways  This project has exceeded the small projects pathway through completion of the full credit requirements.  

  • Man-6 
  • Hea-1, and  
  • Urb-1. 
IC-8 Sustainable suppliers and ISupply  This project has used at least 3 products or services on the ISupply directory listed below: 

  1. Boral – Concrete supplier 
  2. Bingo – Waste management services 
  3. Xypex – Concrete additives  
Inn-1 Innovation Strategies and Technologies  The Unanderra Project partnered with Makinex to develop and deploy a novel mobile 5kW solar PV electricity generation unit (and associated control equipment) for installation on a shipping container in the site’s temporary compound. This is the first demountable, mobile, plug-and-play solar generation system for temporary construction site compounds. The product was verified as an Australian-First with Makinex and Degnan having developed the container-top solar (CTS) system as a prototype to test engineering properties and assumptions for creating a deployable solar PV system for container tops. Makinex continued refining and developing the system and, in partnership with Kennards, introduced it to the broader markets in Australia and New Zealand. This progression was made possible through the development work conducted for the Unanderra Station Upgrade project 

 

 

Stay up to date!

Stay up to date with our latest publications and news.